Coldwell Banker Sea Coast Advantage
Photos coming

$950,000

5 bd · 3 ba · 3,235 sq ft

512 Middle Street

New Bern, NC, 28560 · New Bern Downtown Historic

Listed 48 days ago

Hive MLSListed by COLDWELL BANKER SEA COAST ADVANTAGE

About this home

An extraordinary opportunity to own the Claudius E. Foy House, one of the most historically significant residences in Downtown New Bern! Designed by renowned architect Herbert Woodley Simpson, whose work helped shape the City's architectural legacy, this exceptional home has been thoughtfully updated while preserving an extraordinary collection of original details rarely found in such remarkable condition. Step inside to a breathtaking foyer featuring a grand turned staircase, exquisite millwork, stunning hardwood floors, handcrafted mantels for six fireplaces (one with gas logs), an elegant formal dining room, and what is believed to be more original pressed tin ceilings than any other home Downtown. The craftsmanship throughout is simply unmatched! Offering five bedrooms, including a primary suite, the home also features a first-floor bedroom (currently used as a den) with a detached full bath, an updated kitchen, a light-filled sun porch, one of Downtown's most inviting front porches, beautifully landscaped grounds, and off-street parking. The insulated attic (1051 sq ft) with an interior stair case could potentially be finished for additional space. As if that weren't enough, the property also includes a recently completed detached studio cottage (406 sq ft) with a kitchenette, bathroom, washer/dryer hook ups, Murphy bed, and living space--perfect for guests, a private office, an artist's studio, or a cool entertaining space. Adjacent to the cottage is a custom storage area/workshop (247 sq ft), offering the perfect space for hobbies, projects, recreational gear, and more. Just a few blocks from the restaurants, shops, waterfront, and cultural attractions of Downtown New Bern, the Claudius E. Foy House represents a rare opportunity to own one of the city's true architectural treasures. Homes of this caliber seldom become available. Note square footage: home = 3367; attic = 1051; basement = 621; studio cottage = 406; storage/workshope = 247.

Facts

Type
Single Family Residence
Year built
1901
Lot
0.14 acres
Community
New Bern Downtown Historic
County
Craven
MLS #
100593015

Features

Inside

  • Walk-in Closet(s)
  • High Ceilings
  • Generator Plug
  • Kitchen Island
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Walk-in Shower
  • Basement
  • Blinds/Shades
  • Gas Log
  • Walk-In Closet(s)

Community

  • Street Lights

Parking

  • Off Street

Heating & cooling

  • Heat Pump
  • Electric
  • Forced Air
  • Natural Gas
  • Central Air

Schools

Elementary
Brinson
Middle
Grover C.Fields
High
New Bern

As listed in the MLS. School assignments can change — confirm with the district for this address.

Monthly payment estimate

$6,185/mo

  • Principal & interest (30-yr fixed)$5,706
  • Property taxes (2025 bill)$480

Estimate only. Rate is the national 30-year average (7.03% as of Sep 24, 2026, Freddie Mac); your rate depends on your lender. Homeowners and flood insurance aren't included — on the coast they vary a lot by house, so get a quote early.

Recent sales like this in New Bern Downtown Historic

HomeSoldBd / BaSq ftPrice$ / sq ft
311 Johnson Street, New BernSep 14, 20264 / 32,984$630,000$211
611 Craven Street, New BernJul 27, 20263 / 32,447$650,000$266
411 E Front Street, New BernJun 25, 20264 / 53,373$945,000$280
214 King Street, New BernMay 26, 20264 / 43,280$690,000$210

Similar size and type, sold in the last 12 months. From Hive MLS records; deemed reliable, not guaranteed.

Buying in New Bern? Local guides

About 512 Middle Street

512 Middle Street is a 5-bedroom, 3-bath home of about 3,235 square feet, built in 1901 in New Bern Downtown Historic, New Bern, Craven County, NC 28560.

At $950,000, it's 107% above the median asking price ($459,900) of the 19 other 5-bedroom listings for sale in New Bern today.

That's about $294 per square foot, compared with a New Bern median of $184.

15 other homes are for sale in New Bern Downtown Historic right now (median asking $640,000); 46 homes sold there in the last 12 months at a median of $352,500, typically in about 60 days.

Across ZIP 28560, 51 5-bedroom homes sold in the past year at a median of $355,170.

It has been on the market for 49 days.

New Bern Downtown Historic neighborhood guideHomes for sale in New BernCraven County homes

Buying 512 Middle Street

  1. See it in person. Pick a time and we'll call to confirm — often same day.
  2. Talk numbers. Tell us what you'd like to offer. It's non-binding — a licensed agent calls you before anything is written.
  3. Have a home to sell first? Our guaranteed sale lets you buy with a firm plan for your current home. How it works

Own a home near 512 Middle Street? See what it's worth — every online estimate side by side, next to real sales in New Bern Downtown Historic.

What's my home worth? →

Questions about 512 Middle Street

How much is 512 Middle Street?

512 Middle Street is listed at $950,000 (about $294 per square foot) as of September 26, 2026. Status: for sale.

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 512 Middle Street have?

5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, with about 3,235 square feet.

What neighborhood is 512 Middle Street in?

New Bern Downtown Historic, in New Bern, Craven County, North Carolina.

How long has 512 Middle Street been on the market?

49 days. Homes in New Bern Downtown Historic sold after a median of 60 days over the past year.

What have homes sold for in New Bern Downtown Historic?

46 homes sold in New Bern Downtown Historic in the last 12 months, at a median price of $352,500.

When was 512 Middle Street built?

1901.

Who is the listing broker for 512 Middle Street?

COLDWELL BANKER SEA COAST ADVANTAGE (MLS #100593015). The Buddy Blake Team can show it to you and answer questions.

Can I tour 512 Middle Street?

Yes. Tap “Schedule a tour,” pick a time, and we'll call to confirm — or call or text (910) 395-1000.

Listing provided by COLDWELL BANKER SEA COAST ADVANTAGE via Hive MLS.