509 Metcalf Street

Video tour

About this home

Welcome to the Annie Dinkins Tenant House, a beautifully preserved 1890s residence ideally situated on one of downtown New Bern's most desirable blocks. Rich in history, architectural character, and thoughtful updates, this distinctive home offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy downtown living with generous indoor and outdoor spaces, off-street parking, and a location just blocks from New Bern's waterfront, restaurants, shops, and cultural attractions. Inside, a welcoming foyer and original statement staircase immediately showcase the craftsmanship found throughout the home. Soaring 9.5-foot ceilings, hardwood floors, handsome hardwood doors, and 14 original front windows (with storm windows) preserve its period character. To the left, the gracious front living room features a large bay window and beautiful fireplace mantel. A double-sided fireplace with a gas insert connects the living room to the adjoining library, where custom bookcases incorporate wood salvaged from New Bern's historic Elks Lodge. At the rear of the home, the floor plan transitions seamlessly to modern living. The chef's kitchen features custom cabinetry by Mike's Custom Cabinets, granite countertops, an island and peninsula, gas cooktop, two dishwashers, beverage refrigerator, separate prep sink, and a deep main sink beneath a large garden window. The kitchen opens to the dining and family rooms, where abundant windows provide views of the screened porch and spacious backyard. A dedicated laundry/pantry room with custom cabinetry and utility sink, along with a convenient half bath, completes the first floor. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a private balcony, plantation shutters, dual closets, and a well-appointed bath featuring a walk-in tiled rain shower with a bench and a classic clawfoot tub. Two additional bedrooms share a renovated hall bath with walk-in tiled shower, while the front bedroom features another striking bay window and plantation shutters. The third floor offers approximately 200 square feet of additional bonus space (not included in the primary square footage), providing a versatile area well suited for an office, studio, playroom, or other flex space. Outside, the large fenced backyard is a rare find in the heart of downtown, with brick walkways and plenty of room to garden, entertain, or simply unwind. Two outbuildings provide valuable additional space: an approximately 110-square-foot storage shed and an approximately 148-square-foot storage/workshop building. Off-street parking accommodates two vehicles. Additional improvements and features include a metal roof installed in 2007 and maintained with periodic repainting, a Rinnai tankless water heater, repainted porches in 2024, improvements to both outbuildings in 2025, and a new Whirlpool stackable washer and dryer installed in 2026. Bonus: this property is NOT in a designated flood zone! Historic character, gracious living spaces, modern functionality, and an exceptional downtown location come together at 509 Metcalf Street--a home with a story more than a century in the making.

Facts

Type

Single Family Residence

Year built

1890

Lot

0.19 acres

Community

New Bern Downtown Historic

County

Craven

MLS #

100601759

Features

About 509 Metcalf Street

509 Metcalf Street is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath home of about 2,598 square feet, built in 1890 in New Bern Downtown Historic, New Bern, Craven County, NC 28560.

At $670,000, it's 93% above the median asking price ($346,900) of the 216 other 3-bedroom listings for sale in New Bern today.

That's about $258 per square foot, compared with a New Bern median of $184.

16 other homes are for sale in New Bern Downtown Historic right now (median asking $682,500); 46 homes sold there in the last 12 months at a median of $352,500, typically in about 60 days.

Across ZIP 28560, 467 3-bedroom homes sold in the past year at a median of $268,000.

New Bern Downtown Historic neighborhood guideHomes for sale in New BernCraven County homes

Buying 509 Metcalf Street

1. See it in person. Pick a time and we'll call to confirm — often same day. Schedule a tour
2. Talk numbers. Tell us what you'd like to offer. It's non-binding — a licensed agent calls you before anything is written. Start an offer
3. Have a home to sell first? Our guaranteed sale lets you buy with a firm plan for your current home. How it works

Questions about 509 Metcalf Street