Buyer Agent Commissions After the NAR Settlement: What Every Wilmington NC Home Seller Needs to Know

Over the last several months, something has shifted in nearly every listing appointment I sit down for with homeowners getting ready to sell. Before we even get to pricing strategy, marketing plans, or staging advice, the question comes up almost every single time: "So what's the deal with buyer agent commissions now? Do we still have to pay them?"

It's a fair question — and honestly, it's one of the most important conversations a seller can have right now. There has been a tremendous amount of confusion in the marketplace since the NAR settlement changes took effect, and a lot of sellers have been told — or have assumed — that buyer agency commissions are simply gone. They are not. What has changed is that sellers now have a genuine choice in how they handle buyer agent compensation, and that choice carries real consequences for how many buyers walk through your door.

Because this question kept coming up, I partnered with a local real estate attorney and put together a clear, three-page explanation, disclosure, and election form that I now walk every seller through at our listing appointments. It lays out the options plainly, explains the real-world implications of each, and gives sellers the power to make an informed decision — not a panicked or misinformed one. Let me walk you through exactly what that looks like.

Why So Many Sellers Are Confused Right Now

The National Association of Realtors settlement that took effect in August 2024 fundamentally changed how buyer agent compensation is disclosed and negotiated in real estate transactions across the country. Before the settlement, it was standard practice for sellers to offer a pre-set buyer agent commission through the MLS at the time of listing. That practice is now prohibited on most MLS platforms.

What replaced it is a system that is actually more flexible for sellers — but because the media coverage was heavy on drama and light on nuance, many homeowners walked away thinking buyer agency itself was abolished. It was not. Buyer agents still exist, they still represent buyers, they still get paid — the question is simply how and when that compensation is determined and disclosed.

I've been doing this since 1998, and I can tell you that the confusion in the current marketplace rivals anything I've seen. Sellers are getting advice from neighbors, from social media, from news headlines — and a lot of that advice is flat-out wrong. That's exactly why I felt it was important to sit down with a local real estate attorney and build a proper, legally grounded document that gives sellers clarity rather than anxiety.

If you want to stay current on what's happening in the Wilmington NC real estate market broadly — including shifts in buyer behavior and inventory — I'd encourage you to check out our post on how the market is shifting faster than I've seen since COVID. The buyer landscape is changing, and understanding it helps sellers make smarter decisions.

Your Three Choices as a Wilmington NC Home Seller

When I sit across the table from a seller at a listing appointment today, I walk them through three distinct paths when it comes to buyer agent compensation. Each has real-world implications — not just legal ones, but practical ones that affect how many buyers see your home, how competitive your offers are, and how smoothly your transaction closes.

The three-page document I prepared with our local attorney lays these out in plain language, with a disclosure that the seller acknowledges they understand the implications, and a form where they make their election. This isn't just paperwork — it's a strategic decision that deserves the same attention as your list price.

Here's what each option actually means in practice for sellers in the Wilmington, NC area — whether you're listing a home in a beach community, a neighborhood near Mayfaire, a family home in Porters Neck, or a property in Leland or Hampstead.

Option One: Offer No Buyer Agent Compensation

Yes, you can offer nothing to a buyer's agent. It is legally permissible. And for some sellers in very specific situations — extremely high-demand properties, unique assets with limited competition, or sellers who are prepared to work exclusively with buyers who have no agent — it might make sense to at least consider it.

But here is the honest, real-world truth: offering zero buyer agent compensation will likely limit the number of buyers who can or will purchase your home. Here's why. Most buyers who are working with a buyer's agent have signed a buyer agency agreement that obligates them to compensate their agent if the seller doesn't. That compensation then comes out of the buyer's pocket — on top of their down payment, closing costs, inspection fees, appraisal fees, and moving expenses. For many buyers, especially first-time buyers and those stretching to afford a home in today's market, that additional out-of-pocket cost is simply a dealbreaker.

Buyers in this situation don't typically walk away from their agent — they walk away from your listing. They go find a comparable home where the seller is offering buyer agent compensation and the transaction is cleaner for them financially. The result for you as a seller? Fewer showings, fewer offers, and potentially a longer time on market — which, as I've written about before, is one of the most damaging things that can happen to a listing's perceived value. You can read more about how sellers unknowingly eliminate buyers every single day.

There are also buyers who simply cannot afford to pay their agent separately. This isn't a reflection of their creditworthiness or their ability to buy your home — it's a cash-flow reality. If your goal is to sell for the highest possible price in the shortest amount of time, reducing your buyer pool is almost never the right strategy. Competition among buyers is what drives prices up and terms in your favor.

Option Two: Set a Specific Percentage or Dollar Amount

The second option is what most sellers are most familiar with, even if the mechanics have changed slightly post-settlement. You decide upfront — before any offers come in — that you are willing to offer a specific percentage of the sale price or a flat dollar amount to a buyer's agent who brings a qualified buyer and successfully closes the transaction.

This approach has the advantage of clarity. Buyer agents know exactly what they'll earn if they bring a buyer to your home, which can make your listing more attractive to the buyer agent community. In a market where agents are choosing which homes to prioritize showing their clients, certainty of compensation matters. A listing that offers a clear, competitive buyer agent fee is one fewer obstacle between your home and a qualified buyer.

The challenge with this approach is that it locks you in at the beginning. If the market shifts, if you get an offer that's slightly below asking, or if the buyer's agent is asking for a fee that doesn't align with what you pre-committed to, there's less flexibility to negotiate in real time. That said, for many sellers — particularly those who want simplicity and predictability — this remains a solid choice.

When discussing specific numbers, I always remind sellers to use our Home Sale Calculator to model different scenarios. Understanding your net proceeds under different compensation structures helps you make a data-driven decision rather than an emotional one.

Option Three: Let Buyers Include Compensation in Their Offer Terms

This is the option that is becoming more and more common in our market — and frankly, it's the one that I find the most strategically interesting as a negotiator. Under this approach, the seller does not pre-commit to any buyer agent compensation upfront. Instead, sellers let buyer agents know — through their agent — to include their buyer agent compensation as part of the offer and terms.

What this means in practice is that a buyer who is working with an agent might submit an offer that says, in effect: "We're offering $X for the home, and we're asking the seller to contribute $Y toward our buyer agent's compensation as part of this transaction." The seller then evaluates the entire offer — price, terms, contingencies, AND the requested buyer agent contribution — as a complete package.

I am personally very comfortable with this approach. I welcome it. My job — the job I was hired to do — is to help my sellers negotiate every aspect of the home sale process. That includes evaluating whether a request for buyer agent compensation is reasonable given the overall offer strength. A buyer offering $15,000 over asking and requesting $8,000 toward their agent's fee is a very different conversation than a buyer offering list price and making the same request. Context matters, and negotiation is where I earn my keep.

This model also keeps maximum flexibility on the seller's side. You're not pre-committing to anything. You're evaluating each offer on its total merits. And in a market where conditions are shifting quickly, that flexibility can be genuinely valuable.

Unrepresented Buyers in North Carolina — What Sellers Need to Know

Here's a scenario that is becoming more common — and one that I want to address directly because it generates a lot of questions and, frankly, a lot of misconceptions. With the unique, direct-to-buyer marketing approach we use at the Buddy Blake Team, we are increasingly seeing buyers contact us directly about our listings — buyers who do not have their own agent.

In North Carolina, a buyer who does not have a real estate agent representing them is legally classified as an "unrepresented buyer." This is a specific legal designation with specific implications. As the listing agent, I represent the seller — period. I do not represent the unrepresented buyer. I can facilitate paperwork and provide factual information, but I am not their advocate, I am not their advisor, and I am not their agent.

Many unrepresented buyers today are sophisticated enough to do their own research. They understand comparable sales, they can read inspection reports, and they often consult with a real estate attorney on matters ranging from contract terms to title issues. North Carolina actually has a strong tradition of attorney involvement in real estate closings, which provides an additional layer of protection for buyers who choose to navigate the process without an agent.

That said — and I want to be very clear about this — I still believe a buyer is better off having a professional buyer agent on their side. The home buying process has dozens of steps, dozens of potential pitfalls, and dozens of moments where an experienced buyer's agent can save you money, protect your interests, or simply prevent a costly mistake. The fact that some buyers can navigate it without representation doesn't mean it's the optimal choice.

It kinda feels like it did before buyer agency existed in some cases — and as a seller-focused agent, that dynamic is not uncomfortable for me professionally. But I want buyers reading this to understand: just because you can go unrepresented doesn't mean you should. If you're thinking about buying a home in Wilmington, NC, please read about the full buyer process before you decide to go it alone.

Why I Focus Exclusively on Sellers — And Why That Matters

I want to take a moment to address something directly, because I know it will cross some readers' minds: if I'm working with an unrepresented buyer on one of my listings, am I making more money? Is there a conflict of interest?

The answer is no — and here's why. On my listings, I get paid the same whether a buyer has an agent or not. My compensation as the listing agent does not change based on whether a buyer agent is involved. So there is zero financial incentive for me to steer buyers away from having their own representation. In fact, my job is easier when a qualified buyer agent is involved — they handle buyer communication, manage buyer expectations, and shepherd their client through the process. That's one less thing I have to facilitate while I stay focused on my seller's interests. 😊

I rarely work with buyers because I've found my true gifting in advising, strategizing, marketing, and negotiating strictly on behalf of sellers. I am a listing agent at my core. I love the complexity of positioning a home, crafting a marketing strategy, and then sitting across the table — figuratively or literally — and negotiating the best possible outcome for the person who hired me to sell their home. That's where I thrive.

If you want to understand the philosophy behind the work I do and why I believe the fundamentals of great representation still win in any market, check out The Work Still Wins: Real Estate Agent Manifesto. It captures a lot of what drives me every day.

You can explore our full approach to seller representation — including how we market homes directly to buyers — at buddyblake.sale. That's our dedicated seller resource, and it walks through exactly how we help sellers keep the most money possible from their home sale.

If You're Buying, My Team's Buyer Agents Are Outstanding

Now, here's the part of this post that's for the buyers reading along — and there are always buyers reading our content, because great real estate content serves both sides of the transaction.

While I personally focus on sellers, the Buddy Blake Real Estate Team includes excellent buyer agents who work with buyers every single day. They are out there showing homes, writing offers, negotiating on behalf of buyers, navigating inspections, managing appraisals, and holding hands through every step of the closing process. This is what they do, and they do it very well.

If you are thinking about buying a home in the Wilmington area — whether that's in a waterfront community, near the beaches at Wrightsville Beach or Carolina Beach, in a family neighborhood in Porters Neck or Ogden, or in a growing community like Leland or Hampstead — our buyer agents are ready to help you find the right home at the right price with the right terms.

Start by exploring buying a home in Wilmington, NC on our site, where you'll find resources on the entire buying process. You can also use our Affordability Calculator to understand how much home you can realistically purchase, and our Mortgage Calculator to estimate your monthly payment under different scenarios. These tools are free, instant, and genuinely useful for getting your bearings before you start touring homes.

You can also set up a property tracker to get automatic alerts when new homes hit the market that match your criteria. In a market where well-priced homes move quickly, being first to know is a genuine competitive advantage. And don't miss our upcoming Open Houses — a great way to tour homes without any pressure and get a feel for different neighborhoods and price points.

Browse our featured listings to see the homes we currently have available, and if you're relocating to the Wilmington area from out of town, our Relocation Services page is specifically designed to help you navigate the unique challenges of buying a home from a distance.

Negotiation Is the Job — Every Aspect of It

One of the things I want sellers to take away from this post is a reframing of how they think about buyer agent compensation. It is not a fixed cost. It is not a fee you write on a form and forget about. It is a negotiable element of a negotiable transaction — and in the current environment, it is more explicitly part of the negotiation than it has ever been.

Every offer that comes in on your home is a package. Price. Closing date. Contingencies. Requested repairs. Seller concessions. And now, potentially, buyer agent compensation. My job is to look at that entire package and advise you on what it's really worth — not just the headline number, but the net result after every element is accounted for. That's a skill. It's a skill that takes years to develop and hundreds of transactions to sharpen.

When a buyer's agent submits an offer that includes a request for $10,000 toward their compensation, I don't panic. I evaluate. Is the offer price strong enough to absorb that request? Are the terms clean? Is this buyer pre-approved and serious? Is there a competing offer that doesn't include the same request? All of that context matters, and all of it informs the counter-strategy I recommend to my sellers.

This is also why I always encourage sellers to think carefully before making their compensation decision based on what they read online or heard from a neighbor. The right strategy depends on your specific home, your specific price point, your specific timeline, and the current inventory levels in your specific neighborhood. A blanket policy — "I'm not paying any buyer agent commission, period" — might cost you significantly more in lost sale price or extended market time than the commission you were trying to avoid.

For a deeper dive into how pricing and strategy interact, check out our Real Estate Tips blog, where we cover everything from how to time your listing to how to evaluate offers intelligently.

What You Should Do Before You List Your Home

If you're getting ready to sell your home in the Wilmington area — or even just starting to think about it — here are the concrete steps I'd recommend right now, before you do anything else.

Step 1: Get a real listing consultation. Not a Zestimate. Not a neighbor's opinion. A sit-down conversation with an experienced listing agent who can walk you through current market conditions, comparable sales, and a realistic pricing strategy for your specific home. That conversation should also include a frank discussion of buyer agent compensation and which of the three options makes the most sense for your situation.

Step 2: Understand your net proceeds. Use our Home Sale Calculator to model different scenarios — different list prices, different compensation structures, different closing timelines. Knowing your numbers before you list is the foundation of a confident, strategic sale.

Step 3: Learn how we market homes directly to buyers. Our approach at the Buddy Blake Team is different. We don't just list homes and wait. We actively market your home to qualified buyers through channels that most agents don't use — which is why we're increasingly seeing unrepresented buyers come directly to us. Visit buddyblake.sale to see exactly how we do it and what it means for your bottom line.

Step 4: Connect with us. Whether you have questions about the buyer compensation changes, want to understand your home's current market value, or are ready to get the process started, reach out to us here. We respond quickly, we give straight answers, and we never pressure you into anything before you're ready.

You can also follow our ongoing market commentary and real estate insights on YouTube and Facebook, where I share regular updates on what's happening in the Wilmington market and what it means for buyers and sellers alike.

And if you want to explore all the resources available on our site, our Site Map is a great starting point — it links to every page, every tool, and every blog post we've published, so you can find exactly what you need quickly.

The real estate landscape has changed. But the fundamentals of smart selling — pricing correctly, marketing aggressively, and negotiating strategically — haven't changed at all. That's what we do, every day, for every seller we represent. And right now, in a market that rewards preparation and penalizes confusion, having the right team in your corner matters more than ever.

We also love meeting our clients in person and in the community — if you haven't heard about our annual Pies & Cool Cars with Buddy event, it's one of our favorite ways to connect with the people we serve. Real estate is a relationship business, and we take that seriously.

Assisted by