48 homes sold in Oak Island in September 2025 at a middle price of $609,500, about $416 a square foot. The middle home took 48 days to sell. Sellers received 96% of their first asking price on average, and 1 home sold above it.
A year earlier, 32 homes sold at a middle price of $610,250 — sales are up 50% and the middle price is down 0.1%.
38 homes came on the market during the month. New construction was 25% of everything that sold.
As this report was written, 231 homes were for sale in Oak Island and 58 were under contract — about 4.8 months of supply at September 2025's pace of sales.
Busiest neighborhoods in September 2025
| Neighborhood | Town | Sold | Middle price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tranquil Harbor | Oak Island | 9 | $534,000 |
| Pinners Point | Oak Island | 5 | $599,999 |
| Long Beach | Oak Island | 2 | $472,500 |
| The Lakes at Pine Forest | Oak Island | 2 | $548,256 |
| Tranquil Harbour Island | Oak Island | 2 | $992,000 |
| Yaupon Beach | Oak Island | 2 | $2,062,500 |
Every month on file for Oak Island
September 2025 elsewhere in southeastern NC
Questions, answered
How many homes sold in Oak Island in September 2025?
48 homes sold in Oak Island in September 2025 at a middle price of $609,500, about $416 a square foot. The middle home took 48 days to sell. Sellers received 96% of their first asking price on average, and 1 home sold above it.
What is the median home price in Oak Island?
$609,500 for homes that sold in September 2025, about $416 per square foot.
Are home prices going up or down in Oak Island?
A year earlier, 32 homes sold at a middle price of $610,250 — sales are up 50% and the middle price is down 0.1%.
Which neighborhoods sold the most homes in Oak Island?
Tranquil Harbor (9), Pinners Point (5), Long Beach (2), The Lakes at Pine Forest (2), Tranquil Harbour Island (2), Yaupon Beach (2).
See what's for sale now
Computed from Hive MLS records of homes that closed in September 2025 in Oak Island. Middle = median; days on market counts every listing period for the home. Inventory figures are as of the day this report was written. Published figures are never restated — a later report may differ as late closings are recorded. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.