$1,099,000

3 bd · 4 ba · 3,798 sq ft

4418 Polly Gully Court SE

Southport, NC, 28461 · St James

Listed 39 days ago

Hive MLSListed by Discover NC Homes

Virtual tour

About this home

There are homes you walk into, and then there are homes you experience. 4418 Polly Gully is one of those special places. Custom built in 1997 and surrounded by sweeping marsh views, this home was thoughtfully designed to celebrate its incredible natural setting. Nearly everywhere you turn, oversized windows and dramatic transoms frame the landscape like artwork. Mornings begin with sunlight filtering into the great room as ibis and egrets move gracefully across the marsh. As the day winds down, settle into the sunroom or breakfast nook and watch the sky transform with the setting sun. Inside, the home has a warmth and character that simply cannot be replicated. Beautiful woodwork, crown molding, solid-core doors, pocket doors and custom built-ins speak to the craftsmanship found throughout. The great room invites you to stay awhile, with a fireplace, wet bar and impressive built-in bookcases and shelving. Just above, a charming library loft feels like a hidden retreat, a quiet place to curl up with a book while still enjoying those remarkable marsh views. The cherry kitchen cabinetry, constructed with wood boxes and dovetailed drawers, continues the home's commitment to quality. Nearby, the sunroom may quickly become a favorite gathering place. Its windows slide open to screens, allowing the coastal breeze to become part of the room. Enjoy your coffee in the great room as the morning light pours in, then move to the sunroom in the evening as the colors change over the marsh. There are spaces throughout the home that invite you to slow down. An elegant formal dining room is ready for memorable dinners. The front study, complete with intricate woodwork, and gas fireplace, offers a cozy place to work or unwind and could also provide flexible sleeping space. A full bath on the main level adds even more versatility. Upstairs, the bedrooms feel like private retreats of their own. Step from one guest room onto its porch and take in the view, while another spacious guest suite offers its own bath, large closet and balcony. A flex room and additional upstairs living space create even more opportunities for guests, hobbies or simply finding a quiet corner of your own. A two-story elevator makes moving between levels convenient. Outside, the relationship with the landscape continues. Trex decking, multiple porches and balconies provide places to sit, gather and take in the scenery, while a seawall surrounds the property's perimeter. The home was built on pilings and includes hurricane protection with shutters, electric hurricane shutters and 3M window film. Even the practical spaces reflect the thought that went into this home, with a two-car garage featuring epoxy floors, a workout room, central vacuum, surround sound in multiple rooms and two 200-gallon propane tanks. And while the setting feels wonderfully tucked away, the best of coastal Brunswick County is close at hand. Oak Island is just minutes away, making it easy to spend the day on the beach, enjoy the water or meet friends for dinner. Access to the private St. James Beach Club on Oak Island is included through the POA, offering owners their own special place to enjoy the beach and coastal lifestyle. The historic waterfront town of Southport is also nearby, with its charming streets, local shops, restaurants, waterfront parks and relaxed coastal atmosphere. Adding even more value to this exceptional property, the home includes a one-time Premier Transferable St. James membership. The buyer has the opportunity to upgrade to a Signature-level membership Signature Social, Sport or Golf for an additional $10,000 upgrade fee, for a total of $10,500, provided the upgrade is completed no later than 30 days after closing. Signature memberships are currently valued from approximately $30,500 to $35,500, making this a noteworthy opportunity for the next owner. But the story of 4418 Polly Gully is ultimately not about its long list of features. It's about waking up to the marsh, watching ibis and egrets sweep across the landscape, finding your favorite chair in the library loft, opening the sunroom to an evening breeze, spending an afternoon at the St. James Beach Club, or heading into Southport for dinner before returning home to watch the colors of the sky change over the marsh. This is a home designed not simply to look at the view, but to live in it!

Facts

Type
Single Family Residence
Year built
1997
Lot
1.43 acres
Garage
2 spaces
HOA
$1,380 / annually
Community
St James
County
Brunswick
MLS #
100596280

Features

Inside

  • Central Vacuum
  • Walk-in Closet(s)
  • Vaulted Ceiling(s)
  • High Ceilings
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Bookcases
  • Kitchen Island
  • Elevator
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Pantry
  • Walk-in Shower
  • Wet Bar
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • Walk-In Closet(s)
  • Carpet
  • Tile

Outside

  • Cul-De-Sac
  • Irregular Lot
  • ICW
  • Marsh
  • Water

Community

  • Waterfront Community
  • Beach Access
  • Gated
  • Jogging Path
  • Maintenance Common Areas
  • Maintenance Roads
  • Management
  • Street Lights
  • Trail(s)
  • Trash

Parking

  • Garage Faces Front
  • Off Street
  • Paved
  • Underhouse

Heating & cooling

  • Fireplace(s)
  • Electric
  • Central Air
  • Ceiling Fan(s)

Schools

Elementary
Southport
Middle
South Brunswick
High
South Brunswick

As listed in the MLS (Brunswick County Schools). School assignments can change — confirm with the district for this address.

Monthly payment estimate

$6,967/mo

  • Principal & interest (30-yr fixed)$6,547
  • Property taxes (2025 bill)$305
  • HOA dues$115

Estimate only. Rate is the national 30-year average (6.95% as of Sep 17, 2026, Freddie Mac); your rate depends on your lender. Homeowners and flood insurance aren't included — on the coast they vary a lot by house, so get a quote early.

Recent sales like this in St James

HomeSoldBd / BaSq ftPrice$ / sq ft
4000 Ridge View Drive, SouthportSep 10, 20263 / 43,392$1,274,000$376
2688 Mariners Way SE, SouthportSep 2, 20264 / 44,413$2,475,000$561
4213 Skeffington Court, SouthportAug 31, 20263 / 43,634$750,000$206
2911 Legends Drive, SouthportAug 27, 20264 / 33,032$910,000$300

Similar size and type, sold in the last 12 months. From Hive MLS records; deemed reliable, not guaranteed.

Buying in Southport? Local guides

About 4418 Polly Gully Court SE

4418 Polly Gully Court SE is a 3-bedroom, 4-bath home of about 3,798 square feet, built in 1997, on 1.43 acres in St James, Southport, Brunswick County, NC 28461.

At $1,099,000, it's 120% above the median asking price ($499,498) of the 186 other 3-bedroom listings for sale in Southport today.

That's about $289 per square foot, compared with a Southport median of $256.

110 other homes are for sale in St James right now (median asking $649,000); 351 homes sold there in the last 12 months at a median of $565,000, typically in about 79 days.

Across ZIP 28461, 621 3-bedroom homes sold in the past year at a median of $392,500.

It has been on the market for 40 days.

Buying 4418 Polly Gully Court SE

  1. See it in person. Pick a time and we'll call to confirm — often same day.
  2. Talk numbers. Tell us what you'd like to offer. It's non-binding — a licensed agent calls you before anything is written.
  3. Have a home to sell first? Our guaranteed sale lets you buy with a firm plan for your current home. How it works

Own a home near 4418 Polly Gully Court SE? See what it's worth — every online estimate side by side, next to real sales in St James.

What's my home worth? →

Questions about 4418 Polly Gully Court SE

How much is 4418 Polly Gully Court SE?

4418 Polly Gully Court SE is listed at $1,099,000 (about $289 per square foot) as of September 23, 2026. Status: for sale.

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 4418 Polly Gully Court SE have?

3 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, with about 3,798 square feet.

What neighborhood is 4418 Polly Gully Court SE in?

St James, in Southport, Brunswick County, North Carolina.

How long has 4418 Polly Gully Court SE been on the market?

40 days. Homes in St James sold after a median of 79 days over the past year.

What have homes sold for in St James?

351 homes sold in St James in the last 12 months, at a median price of $565,000.

Is 4418 Polly Gully Court SE waterfront?

Yes — the MLS lists it as a waterfront property.

Does 4418 Polly Gully Court SE have an HOA fee?

Yes: $1,380 (annually), per the MLS.

When was 4418 Polly Gully Court SE built?

1997.

Who is the listing broker for 4418 Polly Gully Court SE?

Discover NC Homes (MLS #100596280). The Buddy Blake Team can show it to you and answer questions.

Can I tour 4418 Polly Gully Court SE?

Yes. Tap “Schedule a tour,” pick a time, and we'll call to confirm — or call or text (910) 395-1000.

Listing provided by Discover NC Homes via Hive MLS.